Lot's of people were able to view my groups Opening Thriller Death Period in turn we received many positive and negative feedback, here are some of them below:
The majority who were able to provide positive feedback stated that the editing of the opening thriller was of a very high quality. All if not most of who watched stated that the opening thriller possessed smooth cuts on each scene and that the continuity was high very high in consistency. Everyone who watched also found that Krenar's selection of music was very good and that it fitted with the genre of the thriller because it was used effectively and in sync with each scene of the opening thriller. However some of my friends also found the stabbing scene realistic where Fernando got stabbed but he didn't spew blood, some of my friends new about the body and found it realistic that Fernando didn't bleed because in real life being stabbed where Fernando got stabbed would not cause much if not any bleeding. Additionally some of the people at the screening also thought that there were a good variety of shots used within the thriller and that the camera handling was very steady for most of the Opening Thriller however some of my friends, for example Stiv found my groups Ident be to very pleasing and unique, he stated that it looked and sounded like a professional companies Ident as it was simple and attractive at the same time.
Some people including my family wished that walking took less time being in frame in the opening of a thriller because it is unnecessary unless something tense is going to happen. I believe this criticism is true as it's possible that we could have taken some scenes of walking out and the story still would have made sense and would have seemed to go faster in speed based in the story progress.
Another problem which the audience had about my groups thriller is that there wasn't enough context, in short not enough information was given to provide a easy understanding of what was going on and this has proven to be true through my experience of having to explain some parts of my thriller to my family whilst they were watching it. The final criticism the audience gave about our thriller was that some shots could have been used better to give a better angle of the conversations that were in place in our thriller, if this was done then the audience would be more connected to the opening of the thriller and would be more pleased and willing to listen to the dialog spoken.
Monday, 21 March 2016
Screening
Now that my group had finished our thriller we decided that we would start screening it, I shared it with my friends my family and even my schoolmates in hope to receive feedback and opinions whilst also watching it myself.
When I was telling my friends to watch it they asked me what it was for and why we were doing it as well as what we wanted to achieve with it. I replied and gave them the main information like how we were making an opening thriller for our Media Studies AS, after explaining and answering their questions I sent them the link to the video allowing them to see and react for the first time to something me and my group produced. The video was only 3:59s so my friends didn't mind and were actually excited and surprised by the fact that I created an opening thriller, at least 3 of my friends were able to watch and gave feedback.
As well as my friends other teachers and students were able to watch our opening thriller Death Period, I found that everyone was not drawn away from watching it because the opening thriller title was attractive and interesting. My groups opening thriller was put on the screen in class and lots of the seats were taken, all who watched were able to give a bit of opinions for example some said it was good.
When I was telling my friends to watch it they asked me what it was for and why we were doing it as well as what we wanted to achieve with it. I replied and gave them the main information like how we were making an opening thriller for our Media Studies AS, after explaining and answering their questions I sent them the link to the video allowing them to see and react for the first time to something me and my group produced. The video was only 3:59s so my friends didn't mind and were actually excited and surprised by the fact that I created an opening thriller, at least 3 of my friends were able to watch and gave feedback.
As well as my friends other teachers and students were able to watch our opening thriller Death Period, I found that everyone was not drawn away from watching it because the opening thriller title was attractive and interesting. My groups opening thriller was put on the screen in class and lots of the seats were taken, all who watched were able to give a bit of opinions for example some said it was good.
Analysis of Rough Cut
What a Rough Cut says, is exactly what it means and thankfully me and my group were told to create one. We were told to do this before making a final cut as it would allow us to be able to analyse where we could add improvements and where we could fix our mistakes. In turn the rough cut enabled us to be able to think of more improvements and gave us ideas of what we could do before finalising our footage.
To my surprise the rough cut made it possible for people to give feedback immediately on what we did well and what we could have made improvements to. As a result my group was given a much simpler time trying to find mistakes and was provided with tips on what part to improve and what parts to make changes to. Moreover because of audience feed back we were presented with tweaks in scenes where continuity had issues and with scenes where our camera shots lighting could have been improved to either reduce or enhance exposure.
At the beginning of my groups Opening Thriller the first scene shows Fernando the victim walking out his house down the pavement. Although the angle of the camera shot was decent the camera was too exposed however we did not realise this until we gained feedback from the rough cut, so as you can see the rough cut is a vital method in acquiring and identifying ways to improve our opening thriller and without it my group would have missed these mistakes.
Another advantage of rough cuts is that although it allows the audience to give feedback yet it also expresses what they currently think about it and what they think it could become. This will help my group improve our opening thriller as it will provide ideas which we could add to make it accomplish the theme and element of a thriller.
However overall after watching the rough cut myself I had also provided feedback. Personally I was pleased that the shots linked together and worked together smoothly. I also found that our opening thriller did make sense after watching our rough cut so Im glad to say our rough cut made sense and was not in anyway senseless apart from however the last shot where Fernando lies dead in the forest immediately after being stabbed to death.
I do think we can make improvements such as resolving the issues here and there where there are continuity issues due to the camera shot lacking match on action. I also found that there was too much time been taken by some shots where our characters were just walking and so I believe we could fix that by changing the length of the footage in out final cut.
In conclusion I am happy that we produced a rough cut as without it we would probably end up with an end product which wouldn't have shown our full efforts and hard work.
To my surprise the rough cut made it possible for people to give feedback immediately on what we did well and what we could have made improvements to. As a result my group was given a much simpler time trying to find mistakes and was provided with tips on what part to improve and what parts to make changes to. Moreover because of audience feed back we were presented with tweaks in scenes where continuity had issues and with scenes where our camera shots lighting could have been improved to either reduce or enhance exposure.
At the beginning of my groups Opening Thriller the first scene shows Fernando the victim walking out his house down the pavement. Although the angle of the camera shot was decent the camera was too exposed however we did not realise this until we gained feedback from the rough cut, so as you can see the rough cut is a vital method in acquiring and identifying ways to improve our opening thriller and without it my group would have missed these mistakes.
Another advantage of rough cuts is that although it allows the audience to give feedback yet it also expresses what they currently think about it and what they think it could become. This will help my group improve our opening thriller as it will provide ideas which we could add to make it accomplish the theme and element of a thriller.
However overall after watching the rough cut myself I had also provided feedback. Personally I was pleased that the shots linked together and worked together smoothly. I also found that our opening thriller did make sense after watching our rough cut so Im glad to say our rough cut made sense and was not in anyway senseless apart from however the last shot where Fernando lies dead in the forest immediately after being stabbed to death.
I do think we can make improvements such as resolving the issues here and there where there are continuity issues due to the camera shot lacking match on action. I also found that there was too much time been taken by some shots where our characters were just walking and so I believe we could fix that by changing the length of the footage in out final cut.
In conclusion I am happy that we produced a rough cut as without it we would probably end up with an end product which wouldn't have shown our full efforts and hard work.
Audience Feedback for Rough Cut
This is our audience feedback for our rough cut.Thankfully 5 people were generous enough to provide their opinions on our rough cut so I have gone and compiled them together and divided them into pros and cons to give an overall feedback on our rough cut.
This is what they thought went well and was effective:two out of the 5 said that some of the camera work was good good, in particular the tracking shots. They stated that they were quite steady although the some of the recording was done in hand they also liked the scene where the gloved hand came into frames and they said it was quite conventional to see a shot like that in a thriller. - Good edit choice of introducing the janitor mopping the floor and then cutting back to the character outside, coming in.
This is what they thought could have been improved:2 of the people who gave feedback said that some of the shots would have been better if they were wider e.g. when the character walked up the stairs, his head got cut off as he reached the top. They said we should have done practice runs to see how it looked before actually recording. The majority of the people who gave feedback also said that it was obvious that the building wasn't empty as they could hear students in the classes. Another criticism was that the scene where the mysterious figure was creeping up on Fernando could have been improved by rearranging the classroom so that the mysterious figure could sneak up in a straight line behind Fernando rather than sneaking up from the side where he could have realistically been seen by Fernando. They also stated that in one of the scenes the supervisor was smiling so they said that the acting should be improved so that the characters appearance doesn't brake. The final thing they pointed out was that the final scene where Fernando was found dead should of had a slower zoom out as they thought it was a bit too quick.
This is what they believed we had to do to improve our rough cut:
They said that we should shorten our shots as most of the scenes just show the character walking. They believed that it was important to do this as it would help to prevent the audience from not keeping engaged. They also said we should consider zooming in on the scene where the Villain looks at the phone using options on Premier Pro as it would help to keep the Villains identity hidden because if not, the Villains face would have been shown and identified. They also suggested that we should add suitable music in the background which could help enhance the elements each scene wanted to express. The final thing they though we could improve on was to consider re-shooting the killing shot with just a close up of a gloved hand covering the victims mouth. They said sometimes implying death/danger is much more powerful than showing someone getting hurt.
They said that we should shorten our shots as most of the scenes just show the character walking. They believed that it was important to do this as it would help to prevent the audience from not keeping engaged. They also said we should consider zooming in on the scene where the Villain looks at the phone using options on Premier Pro as it would help to keep the Villains identity hidden because if not, the Villains face would have been shown and identified. They also suggested that we should add suitable music in the background which could help enhance the elements each scene wanted to express. The final thing they though we could improve on was to consider re-shooting the killing shot with just a close up of a gloved hand covering the victims mouth. They said sometimes implying death/danger is much more powerful than showing someone getting hurt.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)